Dow Theory
2026-11-16 17:16|34 views
Overview of Theory and Methods
In the field of technical analysis, Dow theory is the originator of all market technical analysis (Technical Analysis, including wave theory, Gann theory, etc.). Although he is often criticized for "reacting too late" and sometimes ridiculed by those who refuse to believe his judgment (especially in the early days of a bear market), it has been heard of by anyone with a little experience of financial markets and is respected by most people. But people never realized that it was completely simple and technical, that it was not based on anything else, it was the behavior of the market itself (usually expressed in terms of indices), rather than the business statistics that fundamental analysts (Fundamental Analysis) rely on.
Foundation
Dow theory has three extremely important assumptions, which are similar to the three assumptions of technical analysis theory that people usually see, but here, Dow theory is more focused on the understanding of its market meaning.
The Essence of Dow's Theory
It is worth mentioning that the founder of this theory, Charles Dao, claimed that its theory was not used to predict financial markets or even to guide investors, but rather as a barometer of general market trends. Most people think of Dow Theory as a means of technical analysis-a very regrettable view. In fact, the greatest thing about "Dow Theory" lies in its precious philosophical thought, which is the essence of it all. In all relevant writings, Rea emphasizes that the "Dow Theory" is designed as an equipment (aid) or tool to enhance the knowledge of speculators or investors, and is not a comprehensive and rigorous technical theory that can be divorced from the basic conditions of the economy and the current state of the market. By definition, "Dow theory" is a technical theory; in other words, it is a method of inferring future price behavior based on the study of price patterns.
six theorem
Theorem 1: Three Trends of Dow
There are three types of trends in any market: short-term trends that last from a few days to a few weeks; medium-term trends that last from a few weeks to a few months; and long-term trends that last from a few months to a few years. In any market, these three trends must exist at the same time and may be in opposite directions.
Long-term trends are the most important and the easiest to identify, categorize and understand. It is the main consideration for investors and less important for speculators. Both medium-and short-term trends are among the long-term trends, and only by understanding their position in the long-term trend can we fully understand them and profit from them.
Medium-term trends are less important to investors, but are a major consideration for speculators. It may or may not be in the same direction as the long-term trend. If the medium-term trend deviates significantly from the long-term trend, it is considered to be a secondary reversal or correction (correction). The trend of secondary reentry must be carefully evaluated and should not be mistaken for a change in the long-term trend.
Short-term trends are the most difficult to predict, and only traders will consider them at any time. Speculators and investors care about short-term trends only in a few cases: looking for the right time to buy or sell in a short-term trend in order to maximize profits or minimize losses.
Classifying price movements into three trends is not an academic game. This is because investors who understand these three trends and specialize in long-term trends can also use reverse medium-term and short-term trends to boost profits. There are many ways to use it. First, if the long-term trend is upward, he can short the financial market in the secondary discount trend and add the size of the long position at the profit of the short position near the turning point of the correction trend. Second, in the above operation, he can also buy the right to buy (puts) or lock the right to buy (calls). Third, because he knows that this is only a secondary turn-back trend, not a change in the long-term trend, he can ride out this correction trend with confidence. Finally, he can also use short-term trends to determine the price at which to buy and sell and improve the profitability of his investment.
The above strategy also applies to the speculator, but he does not hold a reverse position in the secondary turnback trend; his operational goal is to establish a position in the direction of the medium-term trend. Speculators can take advantage of the development of short-term trends and observe signs of changes in medium-term trends. Although his mentality is different from that of investors, the basic principles of identifying trend changes are quite similar.
Since the early 1980 s, the volatility of the market's medium-term trend has increased significantly due to advances in information technology and the impact of computer program trading. Since 1987, fluctuations of about 50 points in a day have been common. For this reason, I (Victor? Sporandi, author of The Principles of Professional Speculation) believe that the "buy-hold" strategy of long-term investing may need to be adjusted. For me, holding a long position in a corrective trend and watching years of profits fade away seems like a senseless waste and torture. Of course, in most cases, after a few months or years, these profits will still appear again. However, if you focus on the medium-term trend, these losses are largely avoidable. Therefore, I think it would be wiser for financial market participants to use medium-term trends as a guideline. However, if you want to get an accurate grasp of the medium-term trend, you must understand how it relates to the long-term (major) trend.
Theorem 2: Main trend (short or long market)
Main trend (Primary Movements): The main trend represents the overall basic trend, usually referred to as a long or short market, and may last for less than a year or even several years. Correctly judging the direction of the main trend is the most important factor in the success of speculation. There is no known way to predict the duration of a major trend.
Knowledge of long-term trends (major trends) is the minimum condition for successful speculation or investment. A speculator who is confident in the long-term trend can make a pretty good profit as long as he has the right judgment on the timing of his entry. Although there is no clear method of forecasting the magnitude and duration of the major trends, historical price movement information can be used to statistically summarize the major trends and the secondary folding movements.
Rea classified all price movements in the history of the Dow Jones index according to type, magnitude and duration, and he had only 30 years of information available at the time. Very surprisingly, there is little difference between the results of his classification at that time and the current 92-year data. For example, the magnitude and period of the secondary folding trend, whether classified separately or in combination with the information on the long and short markets, is now normally distributed almost exactly the same as the information at the time of Rea; the only difference is the number of data points.
This phenomenon is indeed noteworthy because it tells us that despite the breakthroughs in technology and knowledge over the past half century, the psychological factors that drive market price movements remain essentially the same. This is of great significance to professional speculators: the current price movements, amplitude and period are very likely to fall within the limited range of the average (medians) of the historical corresponding data. If a price moves beyond the corresponding average level, the statistical risk of intervening in that move increases day by day. When properly weighed and applied, this knowledge of assessed risk can significantly improve the statistical accuracy of future price forecasts.
Theorem 3: Major short markets
Major short markets (Primary Bear Markets): The major short markets are long-term downward movements, with important rallies in. It comes from a variety of adverse economic factors, and this trend will only end when financial market prices fully reflect the worst possible situation.
The short market will go through three main stages: the first stage, market participants no longer expect the financial market to maintain excessively inflated prices; the second stage of selling pressure is a recession that reflects economic conditions and corporate surpluses; the third stage is from The disappointing selling pressure of a sound financial market, regardless of value, many people are eager to cash in at least part of the financial market. There are several dimensions to this definition that need to be clarified. "Important rallies" (secondary corrections) are characteristic of short markets, but neither the "industrial index" nor the "transport index" will ever cross the top of the long market, nor will both indices cross the highs of the previous medium-term trend at the same time. "Adverse economic factors" are the results of (almost without exception) government actions: intervention legislation, very serious tax and trade policies, irresponsible monetary or fiscal policies, and major wars.
Individuals have also classified market indices from 1896 to the present according to the "Dow Theory", listing some of the characteristics of the short market here:
1. From the previous high in the long market, the average decline in the short market (median) was 29.4 per cent, with 75 per cent falling between 20.4 and 47.1 per cent.
2. The average duration of the short market is 1.1 years, of which 75 per cent is between 0.8 and 2.8 years.
3. At the beginning of the short market, the high of the previous long market is usually "tested" with low volume, followed by a large number of sharp falls. The so-called "test" means that the price is close to and will never cross the previous high. The "test" period, low trading volume indicates a loss of confidence, which can easily evolve into "no longer expect financial markets to maintain overinflated prices".
4. After a considerable degree of decline, there will suddenly be a sharp rise in the secondary turn-back trend, and then a small consolidation and volume reduction trend, but in the end will still fall to a new low.
5. The confirmation date of the short market (confirmation date) is the date on which both market indices break downward through the most recent correction low in the long market. It is not an abnormal phenomenon that there may be a gap in the time of the two index breakthroughs.
6. The medium-term rebound of the short market usually shows an upside-down "V-shape", in which the volume of low prices is high, while the volume of high prices is low. Regarding the short market situation, Raya's other observation is very worthy of attention:
At the end of the short market, the market has become immune to further bad news and pessimism. However, after a serious setback, prices also seem to have lost their ability to rebound, and all the signs are that the market has reached equilibrium, speculation is inactive, and selling will no longer depress prices, but the buying power is clearly not enough to push prices up ...... The market is shrouded in pessimism. For these reasons, prices will show a narrow consolidation trend. Once this narrow trend is clearly broken upward ...... the market index will appear one wave after another higher upward trend, which is mixed with the decline did not fall below the low of the previous wave of decline. This time... clearly shows that long speculative positions should be established.
Theorem 4: Major long markets
Major long markets (Primary Bull Markets): A major long market is an overall upward trend, with a secondary fold-back trend that lasts longer than two years on average. During this period, as economic conditions improved and speculative activity increased, investment and speculative demand increased, thus pushing up financial market prices. There are three stages in the long market: the first, when confidence is restored in the future boom; the second, when financial markets react to known improvements in corporate surpluses; and the third, when the speculative boom turns hot and prices inflate significantly-a stage where prices rise based on expectations and hopes.
This definition also needs to be clarified. The characteristic of the long market is that all the major indexes continue to rise together, pulling back the trend will not fall below the low of the previous sub-discount trend, and then continue to rise and innovate high prices. In the secondary's turn-back trend, the index will not fall below the previous important low at the same time. The important characteristics of the main long markets are as follows:
1. From the low point of the previous short market, the price increase in the main long market averaged 77.5 per cent.
2. The average period length of the major long markets is two years and four months (2.33 years). Of all long markets in history, 75% have periods longer than 657 days (1.8 years) and 67% are between 1.8 and 4.1 years.
3. The beginning of the long market, and the last wave of the short market's secondary return trend, there is almost no difference between the two, only waiting for the time to confirm.
4. The secondary turn-back trend in the long market, the decline is usually more severe than the previous and subsequent rally. In addition, the volume at the beginning of the turn-back trend is usually quite large, but the volume at the low point is low.
5. The confirmation day of the long market is the day when both indices break the high of the previous correction of the short market upward and continue to rise upward.
Theorem 5: Secondary foldback trend
Secondary turn-back trend (Second Reactions): As far as the discussion here is concerned, the secondary turn-back trend is an important downward trend in the long market or an important upward trend in the short market, which usually lasts for three weeks to several months. The range of foldback during this period is 33% to 66% of the main trend range after the end of the previous secondary foldback trend. The secondary turn-back trend is often mistaken for a change in the main trend, because the initial trend of the long market may obviously only be the secondary turn-back trend of the short market, and the opposite will occur after the top of the long market.
A secondary turn-back trend (correction trend; correction) is an important medium-term trend, which is a major turn-back trend against the main trend. Judging which is the "important" medium-term trend against the main trend is the most microsecond and difficult part of the "Dow theory"; for speculators with high credit expansion, any miscalculation may have serious financial consequences.
To determine whether the medium-term trend is a correction, it is necessary to observe the relationship between volume, the historical probability of correction, the general attitude of market participants, the financial situation of individual enterprises, the overall situation, the policy of the Federal Reserve Board, and many other factors. Trends do have some subjective elements in classification, but the accuracy of judgment matters. It is often difficult, if not impossible, for us to judge whether a trend is a secondary turn-back trend or the end of a major trend.
My personal research is quite consistent with Rea's view that the reentry amplitude of most secondary correction trends is about 1/3 to 2/3 of the previous major trend band (primary swing; The main trend between the two secondary reentry trends) lasts between three weeks and three months. For all historical corrections, 61 per cent of these were between 30 and 70 per cent of the previous major trend band, 65 per cent of them were between three weeks and three months, and 98 per cent of them were between two weeks and eight months.The speed of price change is another obvious feature, with the tendency of the secondary reentry trend to rise and fall sharply relative to the main trend.
Secondary foldback movements are not to be confused with minor foldback movements, which often appear in primary and secondary movements. The mini-turn-back trend is against the medium-term trend and, in 98.7 per cent of cases, lasts no more than two weeks (including weekly holidays). They have almost no effect at all on medium-and long-term trends.
In Rea's definition of the secondary reentry trend, there is a key adjective: "important". Generally speaking, any price movement is important if it is caused by a change in economic fundamentals rather than a technical adjustment, and its price change is more than 1/3 of the previous major trend band. For example, if the Fed were to raise the ratio of self-financing in financial markets from 50 per cent to 70 per cent, this would cause considerable selling pressure in the market, but this would not be clearly related to economic fundamentals or business conditions. This price movement is a small (unimportant) movement. On the other hand, if a severe earthquake causes half of California to sink into the Pacific Ocean, financial markets will plunge 600 points in three days, which is an important trend because the surpluses of many companies will be affected. However, the difference between the small-fold trend and the secondary correction trend is not necessarily very obvious, which is also one of the subjective components of the "Dow theory.
Rea likened the secondary foldback to the pressure control system in a boiler. In the long market, the secondary turn-back trend is quite a safety valve, it can release the overbought pressure in the market. In a short market, the secondary correction trend is equivalent to adding fuel to the boiler to supplement the pressure of oversold losses.
Richard, editor of Forbes magazine in the 1820 s. Schabak, who inherited and developed Dow's views, studied how to apply the important technical signals that appear in the "price average index" to individual financial markets. And published in 1948 by John? McGee, Robert? D? Edward's book "Technical Analysis of Financial Market Trends" inherited and carried forward the ideas of Charles? Dow and Richard? Shabak, and is now considered to be the authoritative work on trend and pattern identification analysis.
Theorem 6: Dow Theory Important Principle Index Confirmation
Dow theory tells us that the market absorbs everything, and the butterfly effect tells us that things are universally connected. The two indices must confirm each other. Index confirmation is one of the most important principles in Dow's theory, which is the Shanghai Composite Index and the Shenzhen Composite Index in China. A trend can only be confirmed if the two indices confirm each other, I .e. show the same or similar fluctuations. And the behavior of a single index is not an effective signal of a trend reversal. The result of mutual confirmation is to point to the essence of things. The level of technical analysis is not good, and the analysis of macroeconomics is not good. It is not possible to do financial markets like this. Policy is not a panacea and no bets should be placed on it. When you look at market trends with Dow theory, there are no policy options at all.
Based on the analysis of the barometer based on the Dow theory, we find that a "line" of the average index (in a sufficiently long period of time, under normal trading volume, continuous closing prices fluctuate within a narrow range) must imply hoarding or selling behavior, and once the average index moves beyond this line (up or down), it can be assumed with certainty that there will be a secondary or even fundamental change in the direction of market movement. Dow theory, focusing on morphological analysis. In summary, there are bottom or top reversal patterns and short-term correction relay patterns. The first target is measured, so the form is based on the maximum width of the form space, and the first target for the rise and fall of the broken neckline is the maximum width of the form space. After the first target is reached, the second target is set, that is, twice the width, and so on. This is particularly emphasized by the classical Dow theory.
Financial markets are never constant, they are sometimes active, sometimes quiet, either up or down, fluctuating in a fixed range, and once financial markets start a new trend, they usually follow a more fixed path. Wall Street refers to this line as the "line of least resistance". In the absence of a clear trend in the market will not participate in the operation. Fully in line with the description of Dow Theory, establish a position in the right place of the secondary adjustment wave and do not chase a strong trend. Earn that portion of the money you can grasp. When the direction is right, patience waits to expand the fruits of victory, but gradually decreases the number of holdings in a pyramid manner. Escape quickly and get out as soon as you exceed the stop loss level.
Defects
First, let's look at the "second guess" that authors often use when discussing the Dow theory, a kind of accusation that often occurs (unfortunately, often) whenever the opinions of Dow theorists disagree at critical moments. Even the most experienced and careful analysts of Dow theory have found it necessary to change their views when a range of market behaviour fails to support their speculative positions. They don't deny this-but they believe that in a long-term trend, the losses caused by such temporary measures are minimal. Many Dow theorists have published their views on a regular basis to help traders in their trading, and in the previous chapters, if the reader pays attention to such a record, he will find that the exposition given at the time was made in advance by the recognized Dow analysts of the time. "The signal is too late. This is a more obvious deficiency. Sometimes by this very unrestrained comment, "Dow Theory is an extremely reliable system because it causes traders to miss the first 1/3 and the last 1/3 stages in every major trend, sometimes without any intermediate 1/3 stages."
Or simply give a typical example: the 1942 round of major bull markets started with the industrial index 92.92 and ended with the 212.5 of 1946, with a total increase of 119. 58 points. However, a strict Dow theorist will not buy until the industrial index rises to 125.88, and will not sell until the price falls to 191.04. Therefore, the profit will not exceed 65 points or exceed half of the total, this classic case is irrefutable.
But the usual answer to this objection is: "to find a trader who first buys at 92.92 (or within five points of this level), then holds 100 per cent of his position for years throughout the bull market and finally sells at 212.50, or within five points of this level", the reader can try it; in fact, he will find that, it's hard to even identify a group of people who do as well as the Dow Theory.
Since it includes all the disasters of every bull and bear market in the past 60 years so far, a better answer is to study the trading records of the past 60 years in detail. We have the privilege of obtaining the consent of Mr. Charlie Dalton to reproduce the results of his calculations as follows. Theoretically, this calculation can indicate such a situation. An investment of only $100 was put into the financial markets of the Dow Jones Industrial Average on July 12, 1897, at a time when the Dow Theory emerged as a bull market that would be sold or bought again only if, and only if, one of the major trends confirmed by the Dow Theory's proof turned around.
